Category Archives: Tips and tricks

The London Weekly circulation claims – identical to The Metro (Scotland)

Why is The London Weekly claiming a circulation in "the central belt" when the central belt is in Scotland? The answer appears to be found in the media pack of the Metro newspaper in Scotland, which was making the same circulation claims as The London Weekly is – in 2007.

This detail of the investigation into The London Weekly was first mentioned by chrisunlimited in the comments to a Guardian article, but I thought it worth blogging here as we've now cached the Metro's media pack and screengrabs of the salient passages in that and on The London Weekly's website. They're included in this post for your perusal…

LondonweeklycircMetrocirc

Help Me Investigate latest

Hello there.

Well, I thought I’d send out an update on the latest happenings on Help Me Investigate. So here it is:

We’re looking at doing some mobile things with Help Me Investigate. As part of that we need to know what networks people are currently on – so please answer a simple question at http://answers.polldaddy.com/poll/2750023/ to help.

On the site there’s been a huge amount of activity around the investigation into The London Weekly. Some of the details unearthed were mentioned on this week’s Guardian Media Talk podcast (around the 18:30 mark), and there’s more detail on the investigation on this post by James Ball, as well as two earlier posts he wrote: an open letter to The London Weekly and this one. Judith Townend at Journalism.co.uk published this overview of some of the findings. And I also blogged a roundup on the Online Journalism Blog.

The key challenge now is finding documentary evidence and witnesses to back up what’s going on. All help welcome.

Another investigation that’s unearthing some useful results is Hannah Flynn’s investigation into the availability of hormonal contraception on the NHS – Hannah has put together a map indicating the differing availability on her blog.

If you’re looking for something to get your teeth into, challenges that need taking on on other investigations include:

That’s it. Don’t forget to answer the anonymous poll!

Paul Bradshaw
Founder, Help Me Investigate http://helpmeinvestigate.com
Follow HMI on Twitter http://twitter.com/helpmeinvestig8
Help Me Investigate fan page on Facebook 
Help Me Investigate Facebook group

The London Weekly investigated – roundups

The investigation into The London Weekly was mentioned on this week's Guardian Media Talk podcast (around the 18:30 mark).

For more detail on the investigation see this post by James Ball, as well as two earlier posts he wrote: an open letter to The London Weekly and this one.

Investigated: council coverage in the Witney Gazette, Banbury Cake and Cotswold Journal

Three more local newspapers have been covered as part of the investigation into local council coverage.

The Witney Gazette sees 2.5 of its 20 pages of news devoted to council affairs in the local and surrounding council authorities;

The Banbury Cake sees 1.25 of its 13 pages of news devoted to council affairs – although the dominance of advertising means there are actually only the equivalent of around 4.5 news pages when that is taken into account.

The Cotswold Journal had around 26 pages of news, although 4 of those are dominated by ads. Of the remaining space, 2 pages are devoted to the local council and a few more that cover neighbouring councils. Nell Darby writes:

“Perhaps what the Cotswold Journal shows best is that it must be pretty much impossible to get adequate council coverage in the newspaper given the limited staffing and the large area the paper covers. Attending county, district and parish or town council meetings in four different counties can’t be feasible – one person can only be in one place at one time.

“Hence a reliance on press releases or short, less detailed, stories. Where there are longer stories, human interest seems to be a factor – profiles are popular. Often, the council perspective seems to be a last minute insertion or an extra quote, rather than being the nub of the story.”

The investigation continues. If you want to help look at the same or different newspapers, join it here.

Council coverage in the Lancashire Evening Post

Ed Walker has been looking at council coverage in the Lancashire Evening Post?as part of?the investigation into 'How much local council coverage is there in your local paper?' He writes:

"I found that there were 35 pages devoted to news on 23/11, 25/11 and 27/11 and of these 6.25 pages were given over to ?council reporting?.

"Like others I?ve been finding there is little reporting of council meetings, more stories are created from council press releases and then a few quotes from councillors. It?s also not clear when these councillors were saying these quotes, although the councillors title and ward are always attached."

The investigation continues – join it here.

Council Coverage in The Oxford Times

Journopig has added analysis of The Oxford Times to the investigation into ‘How much local council coverage is there in your local paper?

26 of the newspaper’s 184 pages are devoted to news, and of those:

“We counted the equivalent of just three pages of council stories within this 26 page total, using Sarah’s guide to counting up coverage; but we were being generous by including brief mentions of, or quotes by, councils or councillors.

We were slightly surprised by the findings, as we had been fairly confident that a newspaper of The Oxford Times’ size and status would contain a good amount of council coverage. Its circulation area includes not only Oxford City Council but also district councils such as West Oxfordshire, Cherwell, South Oxfordshire and Vale Of White Horse – which serve diverse rural areas.

“But perhaps The Oxford Times assumes that other regional newspapers – such as the daily Oxford Mail, or the weeklies in the district, such as the Banbury Guardian or Witney Gazette – will cover the councils, and leave it to be more arty and intellectual. 

“We’ll be looking at those other regionals in the very near future to see if they really do pick up that council baton. Because if they don’t, then who does make those councils accountable?”

Council coverage in local newspapers – now there’s a spreadsheet to help you work it out

The investigation into How much local council coverage is there in your local newspaper? now has a handy spreadsheet, thanks to Chie Elliott.

The spreadsheet – available here – will calculate the percentage of any newspaper’s coverage that is based on monitoring the local council. 

Chie writes:

“I have set it up so that every time anyone edits anything I’ll be notified. If you accidentally delete anything, don’t panic. You can either go to Edit and click Undo or, if the error was more extensive, Go to File > Revision history and keep clicking “Older” until you get to the version you wanted. Then click OK.”

She also says she is happy to help if you have any questions or problems.

The investigation has so far looked at The Brighton Argus and Sussex Express, the Birmingham Post and Mail, and the Darlington and Stockton Times, while the Lancashire Evening Post is in progress.

If you can help by looking at any other paper – or inviting someone who could – please join the investigation.